A review of current education industry topics from the publisher of Learning A–Z

“Every day I make an effort to go toward what I don't understand. This wandering leads to the accidental learning that continually shapes my life.”
Yo-Yo Ma, cellist

Bob Holl is the co-founder and VP/Publisher of Learning A–Z. His passion is creating and delivering high-quality educational resources that help teachers help kids learn.

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Struggling, (Sometimes) Failing, and Learning

I recently read a blog based on education consultant Allison Zmuda’s three ‘Myths That Haunt Students.’ Those being that (1) students see learning that comes quickly as a sign of intelligence and learning that requires effort as a sign of their own lack of ability; (2) that school and life are disconnected; and (3) that learning is an orderly process rather than a messy and ongoing struggle.

Many students think there is something wrong with them if they make mistakes. Teachers can help their students learn that most people make mistakes, sometimes every day, and that great learning can occur from those mistakes. After all, failures or accidents have led to many wonderful inventions--penicillin, champagne, Post-It Notes, and the pacemaker. Amazing.

It is equally amazing when children learn from their mistakes. Many children play electronic games. When they make mistakes, their games end. But they do not give up and quit playing. In fact, they frequently become obsessed with playing the games over and over until they master each and every challenge. That is perseverance.

Part of our jobs as educators (coaches, mentors, parents, friends, etc.) is to create safe zones for making mistakes and inspire the kind of perseverance that results in learning naturally from mistakes.

Failure and mistakes are inevitable. Character and great things are built on what we make of those mistakes. Let’s encourage children to take risks. After all, there are plenty of unrealized dreams, inventions, and discoveries.

Comments

Dear Bob, this is a wonderful article setting off a fruitful debate. I wish it gets access to teachers especially the untrained. Parents should also read and internalize this article. We parents often over demand from our children in terms of learning and at the end children get frustrated leading to low esteem and consequently poor performance. We don't give them time and space to explore and learn naturally. Thanks for this article.

The article / is wonderful.Though I'm a special educator I never thought on those lines...It clears a lot of cobwebs & preconceived notions from my mind.
Great!! I'm going champion this idea.

Dear Bob;
Thank you for your article. I can relate exactly to what you mention in your article. I grew up in Bogota, Colombia. One thing that we do grow up with is frustration. As a child, if you are fortunate to have some means, you can't always get what you want, you get what you absolutely need. While I watch our son grow up, it worries me that he gets pretty much what he wants and more, there is no struggle or frustration to strive for something more and something better.

Hi, Bob:

I'm writing from Peru, South America. Thanks for the valuable tips on your blog.
I have a 10 years old boy and I'm glad to say that he enjoys reading. He is at a bilingual school and loves English, so Reading A-Z and the Tommy Tales stories are wonderful for us.
He often fails in perseverance, even in the Nintendo DS games. He first turns off it, but next day or an hour later tries again. I will use your example (and those of the great discoveries by accident) with him.

thanks again.

Hi, Bob,
Thanks for so interesting and useful article. We have to encourage our students not to give up when they make mistakes. Perseverence and practice leads them to self/development and success.

I'm writing from Turkey. Thanks for the valuable tips on your blog. Gül

Thank you for reminding all of us that learning requires perseverance. I am a college student and sometimes I forget this valuable lesson and beat myself up because I didn't understand something fast enough. I'm going to print out your article and paste it in my notebook so that everytime I'm beating myself up, I can look at it and remember what learning really is.

Dear Bob, thanks for the "mistakes" article. I taught fourth grade for 8 years and now am on my 2nd year in grade 2.
Every morning we begin with morning work on the board and I frequently make mistakes as we go over the work,in the hopes that the students will find them. They are always amazed to find out that even the teacher makes mistakes-- thay never know if they we made on purpose or not. I tell them not to worry about mistakes because, worry about not fixing the mistakes. So they look for them now and make it as a challenge to catch the teachr's mistakes and fix them.

Hey Bob,
I totally agree with you. Sometimes I purposely make mistakes to show my students that it's OK to make mistakes. We can't choose our everyday sutuations but we can definitely chose the way we deal with it. Learn to laugh at your own mistakes.

I have an autistic son. We've spent a lot of time learning about Piaget - that if you learn it quickly it was just assimilated, but if you have to struggle to make it fit, you have accommodated and true learning has occurred. Understanding this has helped him overcome the frustrations inherent to his different abilities.

hey Bob,
I respect the opinions which really give an insight to life's problems.Yep,great discoveries happen out of persistence.I hope all teachers and parents understand and spare children of unnecessary burden of studies.It's rewarding to make studying a learning experience --and create perpetual students for life.

Your work is highly commendable.
Great going.
Sarika

This is a wonderful article.It is not only encouraging but aids in looking at mistakes from a more positive perspective. Not only children but even adults would benefit from it.For,aren't the adults most prone to "fear" of making mistakes?
Hope this letter is read by other people as well.
Really great...
Gauri

Dear bob, it's really great sharing the amazing experiences in fact i am practising this in my school i teach upto fourth standard i am getting great response from the parents as well as school authorties. you will agree this is a challenging aspect in country like INDIA mediocore schools practise age old teach methods thanks for the support through this media, i will participate with new ideas to this web.

Anasuya.

hi, i really enjoyed this article and the fresh perspective that you offer to the day to day learning that children are faced with. i will try to draw on this wisdom when dealing with both my own son, who is often easily defeated when he encounters problems, as well as the children i teach.

I think that your blog is very good, very interesting . I found it on Google, Bing, MSN. I will back often.

nice post, i search many times for this and its unique. keep posting and thank you for this post.

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

Remember personal info?