A review of current education industry topics from the publisher of Learning A–Z

“Every day I make an effort to go toward what I don't understand. This wandering leads to the accidental learning that continually shapes my life.”
Yo-Yo Ma, cellist

Bob Holl is the co-founder and VP/Publisher of Learning A–Z. His passion is creating and delivering high-quality educational resources that help teachers help kids learn.

Wednesday, March 28, 2007

Expansion for No Child Left Behind?

The report from the Commission on No Child Left Behind is in. The 230-page bipartisan report calls not only for renewal of NCLB, but also for significant expansion of the Act. “You’re never going to hit a home run unless you swing for the fences,” said Tommy G. Thompson, former Secretary of Health and Human Services in the Bush administration, and co-chair along with former Georgia Gov. Roy E. Barnes. Some highlights of the report:

  • All high-school students proficient in reading and math by 2014
  • Three science-mandated tests between grades 3 and 12
  • Teacher evaluations based on how their students perform
  • National Standards

Sen. Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts, voiced hopes that mandated history tests will follow science.

As I have mentioned before, the intention of No Child Left Behind and the goal of every child being educated is a noble cause. However, we might not want to tell teachers they must coach in such a way that every student is swinging for the fence to hit a homerun. Teachers want their students to get around the bases and know there are many ways to score a run. Good teachers know what works best in their classrooms and for their students’ differentiated needs. If teachers are required to teach the same things the same way to every child, every child will not make it around the bases.

Comments

No law about education should be passes unless there are adequate funds provided from the governmental level that passed it.

I vote for no law about education should be passed at the federal level given education is not a right reserved for the feds. The Tenth Amendment reserves those rights for the states and the people.

San Antonio v. Rodriguez held that education is not a fundamental right.

The feds should be out of the education business and those tax dollars returned to the people.

In my area (an upper middle class neighborhood), I've known several teachers who have left the profession because of the NCLB Act. These are good teachers in good districts, and their loss is keenly felt. Equal opportunity under the law is one thing, but equal outcome is impossible and it is misguided for legislators to insist upon it. I'm sorry to hear that this fiasco will continue. It would be better if we removed the political and social agendas from schools and had minimum standards for teachers, not students.

My aunt suggested this website and she is totally right in every way keep up all your great work

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

Remember personal info?